Customer payout and bank fined for irresponsible lending
February 24th, 2011In a major step towards increasing the accountability of large banks, Deutsche Bank has become the first financial company in the UK to be fined for “irresponsible” mortgage lending.
It has been fined £840,000 by the Financial Services Authority (FSA) and will have to pay £1.5m in compensation to up to nearly 8,000 borrowers.
The FSA said the bank had been guilty of “irresponsible lending practices and unfair treatment of customers in arrears”. Deutsche Bank says it will now contact the borrowers and arrange payments.
According to the FSA investigation, the bank’s staff failed to check if some customers would be able to afford their mortgage repayments if their loan lasted into retirement, didn’t offer cheaper mortgages to some customers who asked for self-certified mortgages and failed to check if some customers had considered where they would live if they planned to sell their homes to pay off their interest-only mortgages.
Deutsche bank’s home loans had been sold exclusively through mortgage brokers to people with a poor credit history, in 2006 and 2007. The FSA said 7,967 mortgages were arranged by the bank during this time, of which 4,211 are still on its books.
The FSA showed that when some of the mortgage customers fell into arrears, Deutsche Bank repeatedly hit some of them with unfair charges which bore no relation to the actual cost of administering their account.
Deutsche Bank stopped lending mortgages in 2008 but is the fourth lender since the autumn of 2009 to be fined by the FSA for mistreating mortgage customers in arrears.
However, it is the first time that the FSA has taken enforcement action against a firm for irresponsible mortgage lending.
A spokesman for the FSA said, “Firms which fail in their obligations to customers should expect not only a substantial fine but also they will have to pay back customers who have been disadvantaged by their failings”.
Following the identification of the issues raised by the FSA in an industry-wide review started in 2008, DB mortgages immediately commissioned a third-party review into its lending and arrears collection processes. Since then, they claim to have improved their oversight of mortgage servicing activities.
This is yet another example of the FSA showing its teeth far too late, after the damage has been done and after the new Government has pledged to abolish the organisation to find a more effective solution to financial services regulation.
This type of action, bringing irresponsible lenders to account and ensuring that others operating in the market notice, is precisely the kind of action that could have helped stave off the crisis a few years ago.



